Scotty Back Home

Past As Prologue

Even as semi-rational beings, it’s sometimes difficult to get our heads around a story as perverse as Scotty Mackay’s kidnapping to — and eventual return from — Micronesia. At this point, however, we know this much: Neil S. Mackay obsessively wants full custody of Scotty. We can argue as to whether this is despite — or because of — the car-bombing death of Scotty’s mother, Muriel Pfeil. Perhaps a bit of both. But… Whatever the back story, Scotty’s return to Alaska was far from a guaranteed success. His father still posed opposition to anything except his complete and total victory — and, if anything, was even more aggressive. And threatening. But no Court loves it when its Orders are willfully disobeyed.

Meet Carolina Mackay Willis

Through all of that, moreover, Neil Mackay faced a seemingly more formidable foe. His most persistent opposition (and repudiation) had come from a woman named Carolina Ross Mackay Willis. His sister. She let her discomfort be known. Expressed it even before Neil Mackay returned to Alaska from his Micronesian misadventure. And on Scotty’s return? The Court did a double take.

Carolina Mackay Willis
Carolina Willis

Here’s Judge Roy Madsen in 1977, before the kidnapping:

Judge Roy Madsen: I’m going to read […] into the record, the affidavit of [Mackay attorney] A. D. Talbot, [who] being duly sworn […] makes this affidavit… “On Thursday May 19th, 1977, I visited for about 2 1/2 hours with Mr. and Mrs. Willis at their home in Eagle River. Mr. and Mrs. Willis frankly said they had been unwilling to grant Mr. Mackay any visits with Scotty since their receipt of the court’s decision and order of May 6th, except that Mr. Mackay was welcome to visit Scotty at the Willis’ home.

“Mr. and Mrs. Willis also said that the only condition upon which they would allow Scotty to visit his father at Mr. Mackay’s residence now or in the future would be if Scotty were picked up and returned to the Willises by a governess or housekeeper licensed or approved by the state of Alaska and by the court. The housekeeper or governess would also have to be acceptable to Mr. and Mrs. Willis. Otherwise they would feel they had no alternative but to resign as Scotty’s guardians.

Here’s Judge Madsen upon Scotty’s return from Micronesia:

scotty

Carolina Speaks The Unspeakable

In her 1977 remarks to A.D. Talbot, Carolina was not speaking theatrically. Nor was she fabricating. She was not, as someone who knew her noted, “the kind of [person] that accuses people of wrongdoing… [she] tries to take a Christian outlook and look and see the best in everyone.” That didn’t mean she was passive. Not in the least.

She had, in fact, confronted her brother. She repeated that story in court, while the Judge in the matter — Judge Roy Madsen — was trying to make sense of their competing interests. Here, she is talking about challenging Neil about his use of prescription drugs.

I said, Neil, what are we going to do about your problem? He said what problem. I said, Neil, let's go to specifics. What about your problem, Neil? After three blood tests, Neil, what is your problem? And he grabs the migraine bottle out -- or the carton, and he said it's the belladonna and I said, no, Neil, it's not. We've never talked like that before. Now we know the known. Before it was unknown. We didn't know what was wrong but now we know, let's do something about it. And I said, we can do something about it. But he said no. 

Problems, Problems

scotty

FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND MEMORANDUM DECISION AND OPINION, May 6, 1977. Judge Madsen

There was, indeed, a severe problem with Neil S. Mackay. Neil S. Mackay was a chronic abuser of barbiturates. He consumed them in the form of migraine medication. And, yes, his migraines were persistent and could be debilitating.

The cause? In 1944, while in the U.S. Marines, he suffered a brain injury. Had a metal plate in his head. The injury was categorized as Chronic Brain Syndrome. It manifested itself in the form of migraine headaches, confusion, difficulty in walking, and slow, hesitant, slightly slurred speech.

On top of that — because of that? — there was also no question that Neil S. Mackay was intractable, even combative. But don’t take my word for it. Here he is in a deposition taken by Robert Wagstaff, Scotty’s guardian ad litem (court appointed attorney). [Q = Wagstaff; A = Neil Mackay]

Q. Then those terms -- what I informed you, was it not, that the Willises felt that they wanted someone else present during the visitations?
A. Well, it was a long conversation and I can’t take anything out of context because it – it appears that your question and my possible answer is so self-serving, Mr. Wagstaff – that it’s pathetic [...]
Q. Well, didn't you tell me that you did not want her present, that she could wait downstairs?
A. No, I said that was an alternative. You said that she wanted to be in the area in case Scotty got sick or anything else. And I said I'd like to spend some time with my boy on a one-to-one basis. And then you insisted that she be there. And I said, well, let's try it. And then my sis -- then you advised me that my sister changed her mind and didn't want to be present and therefore, my visitation was called off again. Now that's what you advised me.
Q. Well, Mr. Mackay, I suppose my recollection is er -- in error then because…
A. Well, I can understand why because you're advocating a different position than I am. I'm trying to tell the truth. You’re advocating.
Q. Well, for the record, my recollection of that conversation…
A. Do you want to take the stand, counselor?

Oh, If That Were The Only Problem

As a mother herself — two children already successfully grown to adulthood — Carolina also knew a thing or two about childrearing. Her brother? Not so much. In court, she told a chilling tale about Neil S. Mackay’s lack of awareness about childrearing basics. His ignorance did not exist at the naive level. It hovered, in fact, at a level closer to absurdly dangerous.

Neil Mackay residence

I was going to the post office. Concerned about my brother’s driving, I pulled down the street next to the Holiday Inn going the wrong way and Neil and Scotty said, look, Carolina. I said, oh. There was a policeman. I pulled into the Holiday Inn. So we can all make mistakes. So then we went on to the post office and we went to the pizza parlor and then when we went back, we went upstairs and I stayed with them [at Neil Mackay’s penthouse apartment].

And Scotty had told his daddy that he thought he could fly. And I said to Neil what did you say? And he said, well, I don’t know. He said he’s just concerned about it.

And I said, oh, my God, Neil. You’ve got to tell him he can’t fly. So I got down and I said, Scotty, now you can’t fly. And he said, oh, I can if I put on a costume. And I said, no, you can’t Scotty. You can’t fly. And I said if you — getting up here is no problem, but you can’t fly out that window. I said don’t you go near those windows.

Carolina Mackay Willis, May 25, 1977, Custody Hearing

That was, of course, a historical problem. Now there was something new. On Scotty’s return to Anchorage, the Willis house was to be guarded around the clock, at Neil Mackay’s expense, by Loomis Security. Carolina Willis, now more than ever, feared someone would try to kidnap the boy. She didn’t rule out his father. Way out in Eagle River it took at least forty-five minutes for police to respond to an emergency call. There was something else:

Scotty Mackay was the sole beneficiary under the terms of his mother’s will and the value of her estate approximated $1,000,000. He was, therefore, financially independent in his own right.  


The Book: Kill Brother, Kill Sister

My latest book is available at Amazon, Barnes & Noble and other fine bookstores (paperback and ebook).

Copyright Leland E. Hale (2026)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *